COVID-19 shut down campuses in March 2020 with almost no warning. Students packed their rooms and left. By May, it was obvious: no ceremonies. No processions, no handshakes, no family photos in the quad. For the first time in the history of American higher education, an entire graduating class got their degrees on a screen.

What followed was strange. The virtual format had no logistical limits, so the speaker roster became absurd in the best possible way. Barack Obama, Oprah, Lady Gaga, Malala Yousafzai, BTS. YouTube hosted a graduation event. Facebook hosted one. Harvard's Conan O'Brien delivered his address from his backyard — from, as he noted, the precise spot where his dog had urinated seven minutes earlier.

The pandemic took the ceremony away. What replaced it was something nobody planned. Whether it was better or worse probably depended on how you felt about your graduating class.

‍

Resilience showed up in nearly every 2020 address, but not as a buzzword. Speakers meant it literally. These graduates had watched their senior years dissolve in real time, and the people at the podium knew it.

Racial justice entered the conversation more directly than in any prior year. George Floyd was killed on May 25, days before many virtual ceremonies. Several speakers addressed it head-on. Others were criticized for staying quiet. The pandemic and the protests became, for many addresses, a single subject.

Career advice was largely absent. With unemployment spiking toward 15 percent, nobody wanted to talk about the job market. Speakers reached for something more basic instead — how to hold yourself together when the ground is moving.

‍

Barack Obama gave two major addresses on the same day. The first went to 27,000 graduates from 78 historically Black colleges and universities, in an event hosted by Kevin Hart and sponsored by JPMorgan Chase. Obama used the occasion — his first major public remarks since the pandemic began — to connect COVID's toll on Black communities to structural inequality. He told graduates that current leaders were "not even pretending to be in charge." It was pointed, and it was covered everywhere.

Conan O'Brien spoke at Harvard's first-ever virtual commencement from his backyard. He opened with archival footage of a standing ovation, a Blue Angels flyover, and blasting cannons — the full ceremony he couldn't provide. Then he noted the setting: "This is the spot where my dog urinated seven minutes ago." He dropped the jokes eventually. "You've been handed more than your share," he told them, listing what they'd lived through: 9/11, mass shootings, two recessions, now this. It landed.

Oprah Winfrey keynoted Facebook's Graduation 2020 event alongside Malala Yousafzai, Simone Biles, and Miley Cyrus. Tim Cook delivered a virtual address to Ohio State on values and leadership.

‍

Wichita State University had invited Ivanka Trump to deliver its commencement address. After George Floyd's killing and President Trump's response to the protests, the university president canceled the invitation. It became a national story — less about Ivanka Trump than about the position universities found themselves in during a spring when a pandemic and a civil rights reckoning arrived at the same time.

Speakers who said nothing about racial justice were noticed for it. That was new.

‍

Approximately 2 million bachelor's degrees were awarded in the United States in 2019-2020 — almost none with a traditional ceremony. By October 2020, the unemployment rate for recent college graduates had hit 12.8 percent, more than double the pre-pandemic level.

About one in four recent graduates returned to school rather than entering the workforce. YouTube's "Dear Class of 2020" event drew millions of viewers — the largest virtual graduation audience ever assembled, though the definition of "graduation audience" had to shift to make that true.